Skip to content
Thursday 22 May 2025
  • Home
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact
The Frontier
Click to read
The Frontier
  • News
  • Crime
  • Politics
  • Headlines
  • Education
  • Health
  • Business & Economy
  • Sports
  • More
    • International
    • Religion
    • Entertainment
    • Info Tech
    • Matilda Showbiz
      • Gists
      • Music
      • Gossips
      • Oga MAT
      • Romance
    • Arts & Culture
    • Environment
    • Opinion
    • Features
    • Epistles of Anthony Kila
    • EyeCare with Dr Priscilia Imade
The Frontier
  • News
  • Crime
  • Politics
  • Religion
  • Headlines
  • Education
  • International
  • Business & Economy
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Arts & Culture
  • Environment
  • Health
  • Matilda Showbiz
    • Gists
    • Music
    • Gossips
    • Oga MAT
    • Romance
  • Opinion
  • Epistles of Anthony Kila
  • EyeCare with Dr Priscilia Imade
  • Info Tech
  • Interview
The Frontier
Click to read
International
International

U.S. court declines request seeking release of Tinubu’s FBI record

The FrontierThe FrontierOctober 31, 2023 4266 Minutes read0

The United States (U.S.) Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has foreclosed the possibility of making public any documents or information relating to President Bola Ahmed Tinubu.

The FBI stated its position on the issue in a suit it filed before the United States District Court of Columbia by one Aaron Greenspan, who is seeking to compel U.S. security agencies, including the FBI to release some purported documents and information about Tinubu and “Mueez Adegboyega Akande (deceased as of 11/16/2022).”

The response, dated October 30 is in relation to Greenspan’s application for the court to reconsider its ruling of October 23, rejecting his emergency motion for the release of the documents and information he is seeking in the substantive suit he filed under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA).

In the court document, titled: “Defendants’ response to plaintiff’s for reconsideration,” it was “in plaintiff’s motion for reconsideration, he argues that the court is wrong because FOIA exemptions had already been largely, or at least partially, overcome according to the representations by defendants in their September 11, 2023 Joint Status Repost.

“Plaintiff entirely misapprehends the Joint Status Report. None of the parties has conceded any FOIA exemptions.

“As to the actions that certain defendants agreed to take by the end of October, the FBI stated that it will release records relating to the two FOIA requests that sought records involving other individuals, not Tinubu.

“As to the Tinubu requests, the FBI asserted Exemptions (b)(6) and (b)(7)(C) Glomar response and neither confirmed nor denied the existence of records sought in those requests.

“State and Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys (EOUSA) stated that they anticipate sending initial responses – not necessarily documents.

“Absent any unforeseen circumstances, FBI, State, and EOUSA will comply with their representations made in the Joint Status Report.

“As to irreparable injury, plaintiff now concedes that ‘it is likely that this injury has already transpired’ and does not even contend – let alone establish – that the public interest outweighs the privacy interests, or that the equities favour his position.

“Defendants reiterate that they oppose plaintiff’s characterization of the Joint Status Report filed September 11, 2023.

“Plaintiff states, ‘defendants acknowledged that plaintiff’s FOIA requests were valid and waived and/or reversed many of their prior erroneous denials and objections.’

“Plaintiff contends that the defendants made ‘existing promises to produce documents.’

“The only party that has acknowledged responsive documents that are not subject to an exemption and will be produced is the FBI, who will produce records not related to Tinubu. No exemptions have been waived.

“For these reasons, the court should deny plaintiff’s motion for reconsideration.”

In June, Greenspan filed the civil suit, marked 23 – 1816 under the FOIA, against the EOUSA, Department of State (DOS), FBI, Internal Revenue Service (IRS), Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA), and the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA).

He alleged that the defendants – EOUSA, DOS, FBI, IRS, DEA and the CIA violated the FOIA by “failing to issue determinations within the statutory deadline,” “failing] to conduct reasonable searches for records,” and “failing to produce records responsive to” his FOIA requests.

Greenspan had, in an FOIA request to the EOUSA, sought for “records from the Northern District of Illinois and/or Northern District of Indiana involving charging decisions for the following individuals – Bola Ahmed Tinubu (President of Nigeria as of 2/2023” and “Mueez Adegboyega Akande (deceased as of 11/16/2022.”

He told the court, among others, that his request for prompt release of the documents, even before the hearing scheduled for October 31 was because “the Nigerian Supreme Court will hear an appeal of a judicial tribunal’s decision confirming Mr. Tinubu as President of Nigeria on Monday, October 23, 2023.”

Greenspan claimed that the Supreme Court deliberately moved the hearing of the appeals by Atiku and Obi to yesterday to render his suit before the U.S court nugatory, contending that the documents he requested for “would likely be directly relevant to the foreign proceedings in Nigeria.”

In his October 23 ruling, Judge Beryl A. Howell of the US District Court of the District of Columbia, held among others that Greenspan failed to satisfy the relevant conditions for the grant of his prayer for a temporary relief, as contained in the emergency hearing motion he filed on October 20.

Judge Howell further held that Greenspan failed to establish that he is likely to succeed on the merits; that he is likely to suffer irreparable harm if the preliminary relief he sought was not granted; that the balance of equities tips in his favour, and that the relief he seeks is in the public interest.

The judge, who also noted that Greenspan has not established that the purported documents and information he wants the court to compel the defendants to produce actually exist, further held that “neither a preliminary injunction nor a temporary restraining order is appropriate in this case.

“Given that the FOIA request is for records that, if any exist, may be of a highly sensitive and private nature, and that the subject of those documents – Bola A. Tinubu – has had no opportunity to protect his privacy interests in any such records, the balance of equities militates strongly in favour of denying this emergency motion.”

He held that the position of the law is that, in such a case, the plaintiff bears the burden of proving that he/she is likely to succeed on the merits of the case.

Judge Howell added: “In plaintiff’s underlying FOIA request and complaint, he seeks documents relating to purported federal investigations into President Tinubu.

“As previously noted, EOUSA originally denied plaintiff’s FOIA request, invoking FOIA Exemptions 6 and 7(c), which protect information that would constitute unwarranted invasions of personal privacy and information compiled for law enforcement purposes that may constitute an unwarranted invasion of the personal privacy of a third party.

“Plaintiff has failed even to attempt to argue how his request may overcome those exemptions and achieve a likelihood of success on the merits. This failure to address this important factor in his emergency motion weighs strongly in favour of denying his motion.”

The judge also found that the plaintiff failed to demonstrate that he was going to suffer actual and real irreparable injury if the relief he sought was not granted, rather than a mere possibility or theoretical injury.

He added that the “plaintiff falls far short of satisfying this standard. He (plaintiff) has not supplied the court with any indication of a concrete, actual threat that he will suffer in the absence of an injunction. While his emergency motion states that a Nigerian Supreme Court hearing is scheduled to occur in the coming days, plaintiff cites no injury he will suffer that is in any way traceable to the relief requested in this motion.

“Granting plaintiff’s emergency motion would essentially allow him to jump the line ahead of other requests deemed similarly time-sensitive under FOIA’s expedition standards. The inherent tradeoffs implicated in ordering an agency to produce records in a specific FOIA request ahead of others by granting a preliminary injunction thus, must be considered in evaluating the balance of the equities, and weigh heavily in favour of denying such injunctive relief.

“Plaintiff has not made any representation to the court that the balance of equities tips in his favour or that the granting of his motion would further the public interest. For the foregoing reasons, it is hereby ordered that plaintiff’s emergency motion for a hearing to compel immediate document production is denied,” the judge said.

President Tinubu’s lawyers have filed a motion before the court, seeking to be made a party to enable them to defend their client.

 

 

 

 

Tags
CourtdeclinesrequestU.S.
FacebookTwitterWhatsAppLinkedInEmailLink
Previous post 2023 Ballon d’Or: Victor Osimhen ranked 8th best player
next post Saudi Arabia to separate Nigeria’s conjoined twins
Related posts
  • Related posts
  • More from author
International

Trump plays up ‘Genocide’ accusation in meeting with South Africa President

May 22, 20250
International

UK plans new investor visa to attract wealthy foreigners

May 21, 20250
International

Ukraine detained 50,000 men trying to flee since war began

May 21, 20250
Load more
Read also
Inside Akwa Ibom Today

inside the Hill top newspaper

February 9, 20250
Crime

Boko Haram informants among politicians, soldiers — Governor Zulum laments

May 22, 20250
Business & Economy

Nigeria spends whopping $2 billion to service external debt in 4 months

May 22, 20250
Education

Spelling competition exposes poor standard in Abuja schools

May 22, 20250
Sports

Musa, Iheanacho return as coach Chelle picks 25 Super Eagles for Unity Cup tourney •FULL LIST

May 22, 20250
Special

The complexities of citizenship for babies born in-flight

May 22, 20250
Health

Lagos govt sanctions 580 nightclubs, restaurants over indoor smoking

May 22, 20250
Load more

inside the Hill top newspaper

February 9, 2025

Boko Haram informants among politicians, soldiers — Governor Zulum laments

May 22, 2025

Nigeria spends whopping $2 billion to service external debt in 4 months

May 22, 2025

Spelling competition exposes poor standard in Abuja schools

May 22, 2025

Musa, Iheanacho return as coach Chelle picks 25 Super Eagles for Unity Cup tourney •FULL LIST

May 22, 2025

The complexities of citizenship for babies born in-flight

May 22, 2025

inside the Hill top newspaper

0 Comments

Boko Haram informants among politicians, soldiers — Governor Zulum laments

0 Comments

5 burnt to death scooping fuel from fallen tanker

0 Comments

Naira slumps further as dollar scarcity bites harder

0 Comments

BREAKING: Appeal Court sacks Senate Minority Leader, orders election rerun

0 Comments

Again, Trump fined $10,000 for violating gag order

0 Comments

Follow us

FacebookLike our page
InstagramFollow us
YoutubeSubscribe to our channel
WhatsappContact us
Latest news
1

inside the Hill top newspaper

February 9, 2025
2

Another female police officer appointed as Force Secretary

August 28, 2024
3

Oyo set to move against unregistered travel, tour agencies

March 17, 2025
4

Recapitalisation Watch: Banks post divergent results for week ended Sept 20

September 23, 2024
5

Reps revisit Oronsaye Report to streamline government agencies

July 3, 2024
6

Senate probes dumping of substandard diesel in Nigeria

July 3, 2024
Popular
1

inside the Hill top newspaper

February 9, 2025
2

Voters defy rain to vote in Edo governorship election

September 21, 2024
3

Ondo State Govt set to amend chieftaincy declaration to check crisis

January 2, 2025
4

Donald Trump’s wife Melania opens up about attempts on ex-president’s life

September 26, 2024
5

Alleged sexual harassment: Women set to protest in support of Senate President Akpabio at UN House tomorrow

March 13, 2025
6

Final US election results: Trump wins Arizona, secures 312 electoral votes •FULL RESULTS

November 11, 2024

About The Frontier

The Frontier is Nigeria’s leading online newspaper. It is published by Okims Media Links Limited headed by Sunny Okim, a veteran journalist who is widely known as The Grandmaster, fondly called so by colleagues and friends for being Nigeria’s pioneer movie journalist.

Most viewed

inside the Hill top newspaper

February 9, 2025

Experts see Naira trading at N2000/$, say CBN overwhelmed

January 29, 2024

Forex crisis: Declare cashless policy – Investment analyst tells Tinubu

November 30, 2023

JUST IN: Niger Delta communities threaten to cripple oil production over Nnamdi Kanu’s continued detention

June 27, 2024

Husband kills wife over cooking argument in Lagos

December 19, 2023
Top posts

Categories

  • News2727
  • Crime2366
  • Politics2136
  • International1482
  • Business & Economy1473
  • Headlines1382
  • Sports1252
  • Education772
  • Matilda Showbiz527
  • Health468
  • Entertainment395
  • Religion280
  • Hunger protests in Nigeria220
  • Environment217
  • Special200
  • Africa153
  • Info Tech145
  • Arts & Culture131
  • Interview101
  • Opinion80
  • EyeCare with Dr Priscilia Imade66
  • Inside Akwa Ibom Today57
  • Epistles of Anthony Kila19
  • Advert15
  • Local News4
  • Trends4

© 2025 The Frontier, Published by Okims Media Links Limited.

designed by winnet services

  • Home
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact